UK immigration judge rejects claim of asylum seeker who didn’t have a gay ‘demeanour’

UK immigration judge rejects claim of asylum seeker who didn’t have a gay ‘demeanour’
News
Posted on 21 Aug 2019

The asylum claim of a man from a country where homosexuality is illegal has been rejected by a UK immigration judge - in part, according to the claimant’s lawyer, because her client didn’t have a gay ‘demeanour’.


The judge refused to accept that the man was homosexual, contrasting his appearance with that of a witness who the judge did accept was gay, and who ‘wore lipstick’, had an ‘effeminate’ manner and was a member of a gay-community organisation.

The Guardian reports that the claimant’s barrister, Rehana Popal, said of the judge: “He has taken a stereotype, used it as a benchmark and compared my client to it. That is totally wrong. You do not need to dress a certain way, carry yourself a certain way or look a certain way to be homosexual. The only thing that makes a person gay is if they are attracted to someone of the same gender.”


Ms Popal described the judge’s comments as being like something “from the 16th century”.

Home Office guidance to asylum caseworkers states that they ‘must not stereotype the behaviour or characteristics of gay or bisexual persons’, and that sexual orientation is about a person’s capacity for “profound emotional, affectional and sexual attraction”.


A spokesperson for the Home Office said: “The UK has a proud record of providing protection for asylum seekers fleeing persecution. Each case is considered on its individual merits by experienced caseworkers, with all available evidence carefully and sensitively considered in light of published country information.”

HAVE YOUR SAY

Tell us what you think below...

Join our Newsletter today!

More from News...

Most Popular Stories

  • Equality lessons row: LGBT school protest ruling to be challenged in high court News

    Equality lessons row: LGBT school protest ruling to be challenged in high court

    More
  • Equality lessons row: Anderton Park school protesters met with songs of love News

    Equality lessons row: Anderton Park school protesters met with songs of love

    More
  • Tabloid threat forced gay ex-rugby star Gareth Thomas to go public about his HIV status News

    Tabloid threat forced gay ex-rugby star Gareth Thomas to go public about his HIV status

    More
  • Gay former rugby star Gareth Thomas reveals he’s HIV positive News

    Gay former rugby star Gareth Thomas reveals he’s HIV positive

    More
  • Something to SHOUT about! Birmingham's queer arts festival turns 10 this year News

    Something to SHOUT about! Birmingham's queer arts festival turns 10 this year

    More
  • Former PM David Cameron proud to have introduced same-sex marriage in the UK News

    Former PM David Cameron proud to have introduced same-sex marriage in the UK

    More
  • LGBT+ hate crime rise caused by Brexit and social media, says police chief News

    LGBT+ hate crime rise caused by Brexit and social media, says police chief

    More